Search

Who is the best player to have turned out for West Ham and Bournemouth?

PUBLISHED: 19:30 10 March 2017

West Ham's Pat Holland scores past Oldham Athletic goalkeeper Peter McDonnell

West Ham's Pat Holland scores past Oldham Athletic goalkeeper Peter McDonnell

S&G and Barratts/EMPICS Sport

We look at the cream of the Cherries and the Hammers over the years. Who is the best

Steve Jones, Bournemouth Steve Jones, Bournemouth

After the quality of last week’s West Ham/Chelsea rundown of players who have appeared for both, this week’s Bournemouth/West Ham rundown may not have been so star-studded, but it did provide us with some tough choices for out first 11 players.

There were still plenty who missed out on a place in the run-down including goalkeepers David James and Stephen Henderson as they simply did not play enough games for the Cherries.

Striker Steve Jones may have been a little unlucky not to make the list while West Ham stars Jimmy Neighbour and Patsy Holland have also missed out.

There is no place for Bobby Barnes, Jack Collison, Dale Gordon and Elliot Ward, while others are less well-known.

AFC Bournemouth goalkeeper David James during the npower Football League One match at Goldsands Stadium, Bournemouth. AFC Bournemouth goalkeeper David James during the npower Football League One match at Goldsands Stadium, Bournemouth.

Anthony Edgar, Phil Brignull, Zavon Hines, Everald La Ronde, Scott Mean, Keith Miller, Mark Watson and Paul Mitchell.

So who does make our top 11 players who have plied their trade for both and who is our number one?

Blackburn Rovers' Bi lly McKinlay and West Ham United's Keith Rowland battle for the ball Blackburn Rovers' Bi lly McKinlay and West Ham United's Keith Rowland battle for the ball

11. KEITH ROWLAND

Solid, rather than spectacular midfielder, the Northern Ireland international was a good servant to both clubs. Started at Bournemouth and played 72 games for them, before joining the Hammers in a £110,000 deal in 1993. Made 80 league appearances in claret and blue, but injury hampered his time there and he moved on to QPR.

10. IAN BISHOP

West Ham's Ian Bishop slides to beat Notts Forest's Brian Roy to the ball in today's (Saturday) Premiership match at Upton Park. West Ham's Ian Bishop slides to beat Notts Forest's Brian Roy to the ball in today's (Saturday) Premiership match at Upton Park.

Made his name at Carlisle United where he made over 100 appearances, before joining Bournemouth in 1988. Played 44 games for the Cherries, scoring two goals, but reached his peak at Upton Park between 1989 and 1998 after Lou Macari signed him. Made over 300 appearances and with his long, flowing locks became something of a cult figure.

9. JUNIOR STANISLAS

West Ham's Junior Stanislas celebrates scoring during the Barclays Premier League match at Upton Park, London. West Ham's Junior Stanislas celebrates scoring during the Barclays Premier League match at Upton Park, London.

A player who will be looking to make his mark for Bournemouth on Saturday. Came through the West Ham Academy and looked impressive when he broke into the first team. However, was never really given a run of games and was sold to Burnley after 47 appearances and eight goals.

Moved to the Cherries in 2014 and has established himself as an important player on the wing in the Premier League.

8. MATTY HOLMES

MATT HOLMES, WEST HAM. MATT HOLMES, WEST HAM.

Started at Dean Court where he made over 100 appearances for Bournemouth between 1988 and 1992, before joining the Hammers in a £40,000 deal, rising to £60,000

Proved a bargain as he helped West Ham gain promotion, before playing two seasons in the top flight. Made 89 appearances and then joined champions Blackburn in a £1.2million deal.

7. RIO FERDINAND

Rio Ferdinand Rio Ferdinand

The young West Ham star was sent down to the south coast to mature as a player and came back a finished product.

Played 10 games on loan there in 1996/97 and returned to star in West Ham’s defence, making over 100 appearances, before moving on to Leeds United and Manchester United. Earned 81 caps for England.

6. BOBBY HOWE

Bobby Howe, West Ham United Bobby Howe, West Ham United

Came through the West Ham ranks, winning the FA Youth Cup in 1963 and establised himself in the first-team squad. Was a member of the League Cup Final team in 1966 and played 82 games in claret and blue between 1966 and 1971.

Moved to Bournemouth and made over 100 appearances for them in two seasons before retiring. Later played and coached in the United States.

5. CARL FLETCHER

AFC Bournemouth's captain Carl Fletcher celebrates after scoring just before half-time to make the score 2-1 AFC Bournemouth's captain Carl Fletcher celebrates after scoring just before half-time to make the score 2-1

Started his career with the Cherries, making his debut at 17 and played nearly 200 games for them, including captaining and scoring two goals for them in the Division Three play-off final win over Lincoln City in 2003.

Joined West Ham in 2004 in a £275,000 deal, but was in and out of the team, though he did play in the FA Cup final in midfield after Hayden Mullins was suspended.

The Wales captain scored in that memorable ‘lasagne gate’ match which denied Spurs a Champions League spot in 2006.

JIMMY QUINN, BOURNEMOUTH JIMMY QUINN, BOURNEMOUTH

4. JIMMY QUINN

The much travelled, prolific goalscoring Northern Ireland international made his name at Swindon Town and Blackburn.

Signed for newly-relegated West Ham in 1989 in a £320,000 deal and helped them back to the top flight with 18 goals in 47 games.

Earned the nickname of ‘Jimmy the Tree’ for his lack of movement, but had a good return in goals, but was never to play for West Ham in Division One as he joined then Third Division Bournemouth. Spent only one season on the south coast, but still scored 19 goals.

West Ham United's Harry Redknapp (c) takes on Manchester City's Arthur Mann (l) and Tommy Booth (r) West Ham United's Harry Redknapp (c) takes on Manchester City's Arthur Mann (l) and Tommy Booth (r)

3. HARRY REDKNAPP

Obviously best known as a manager for both West Ham and Bournemouth, he also played for both clubs with considerable success.

Started in the Tottenham Youth Academy before moving to West Ham, he broke into the first team as a speedy winger in 1965, finally establishing himself in the 1968-69 season when he played 42 games.

Harry Redknapp of Bournemouth Harry Redknapp of Bournemouth

Finally joined third division Bournemouth in 1972 and played over 100 games for the Cherries, although he could not prevent relegation to Division Four.

More successful as a manager for both clubs and one of the great characters of the game.

2. TED MACDOUGALL

Ted MacDougall, the Inverness-born forward with West Ham United. After a brilliant goal-scoring record in the Third Division, he moved from Bournemouth to Manchester United for a £200,000 fee last September. He joined West Ham in February. Ted MacDougall, the Inverness-born forward with West Ham United. After a brilliant goal-scoring record in the Third Division, he moved from Bournemouth to Manchester United for a £200,000 fee last September. He joined West Ham in February.

An incredible scoring record at Bournemouth for the striker. The Scotland international signed from York City, but despite his 21 goals, the Cherries were relegated to Division Four.

“SuperMac” was not finished there though. He scored a club record six FA Cup goals in an 8-1 win over Oxford City and an incredible nine in an 11-0 FA Cup thrashing of Margate in 1971.

After a superb 103 goals in 146 games for the Cherries, he joined Manchester United in a £200,000 deal, but things never worked out in a United side looking to replace the likes of Denis Law and Bobby Charlton.

Joined West Ham the following season, but things never really worked out for him there either.

Bournemouth's Ted MacDougall heads for goal Bournemouth's Ted MacDougall heads for goal

A dressing-room bust up with Billy Bonds over his lack of effort following a 4-1 defeat by Leeds United, signalled the end of his career at the club, scoring just seven goals in 26 appearances, before he moved on to Norwich.

His Bournemouth statistics earn him such a lofty position.

1. JERMAIN DEFOE

Jermain Defoe, 18, has scored 10 goals in successive league games for Bournemouth, while on loan from West Ham, in action against Millwall at the New Den. Jermain failed to score, in this his 11th successive game. Bournemouth won 1-0. Jermain Defoe, 18, has scored 10 goals in successive league games for Bournemouth, while on loan from West Ham, in action against Millwall at the New Den. Jermain failed to score, in this his 11th successive game. Bournemouth won 1-0.

Still going strong, the beginnings of his goalscoring brilliance came during a loan spell with Bournemouth from West Ham.

The Hammers had poached him from Charlton Athletic and Harry Redknapp sent him out on loan to the south coast where he flourished at the second division side.

Equalled the record for goals in consecutive matches when he managed 10 in a row and he scored 18 goals in 29 league appearances for Bournemouth in 2000/01.

West Ham United's Jermain Defoe celebrates scoring his teams third goal of the game West Ham United's Jermain Defoe celebrates scoring his teams third goal of the game

Established himself at West Ham on his return and scored 41 goals in 105 games in claret and blue.

A controversial character, he put in a transfer request within days of the Hammers relegation, it was denied and in the following season he was red-carded three times before moving to Tottenham.

An England international, he is still a top class striker at Sunderland to the extent that West Ham tried to buy him back in January at the age of 33.

0 comments

Welcome , please leave your message below.

Optional - JPG files only
Optional - MP3 files only
Optional - 3GP, AVI, MOV, MPG or WMV files
Comments

Please log in to leave a comment and share your views with other Romford Recorder visitors.

We enable people to post comments with the aim of encouraging open debate.

Only people who register and sign up to our terms and conditions can post comments. These terms and conditions explain our house rules and legal guidelines.

Comments are not edited by Romford Recorder staff prior to publication but may be automatically filtered.

If you have a complaint about a comment please contact us by clicking on the Report This Comment button next to the comment.

Not a member yet?

Register to create your own unique Romford Recorder account for free.

Signing up is free, quick and easy and offers you the chance to add comments, personalise the site with local information picked just for you, and more.

Sign up now

Latest Romford Sports News

16:00

Daggers duo will head to Slovakia next month

NFC West: Arizona Cardinals 0 Los Angeles Rams 33

13:00

Romford-based potter completed first part of possible quadruple by winning English Open on Sunday

Bostik North: Soham Town Rangers 1 Hornchurch 2

Yesterday, 14:00

The English Open is drawing to a close with the final taking place this afternoon

Saturday, October 21, 2017

Daggers boss has no complaints over 32nd minute dismissal of defender against Robins

Saturday, October 21, 2017

Vanarama National league: Dagenham & Redbridge 0 Wrexham 1 (Robson o.g. 90+3)

Newsletter Sign Up

Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Most read sport

Show Job Lists

News from your area

Competitions

Having a brand new kitchen is something that lots of people want but can only dream of. Sadly keeping up to date and making our living spaces as nice as they can be is a costly and incredibly stressful business. Even a fresh coat of paint makes all the difference but isn’t easy or quick.

Who wouldn’t love the chance to go on a shopping spree. Imagine being able to walk into a shop and choose whatever your heart desires without having to worry about how much it costs.

Digital Edition

cover

Enjoy the
Romford Recorder
e-edition today

Subscribe

Education and Training

cover

Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now