Search

Romford councillor’s Alzheimer’s comment amounted to ‘freedom of expression’, standards panel finds

07:00 14 May 2014

Cllr Damian White did not breach any code of conduct

Cllr Damian White did not breach any code of conduct

Archant

A councillor who publicly proclaimed that a Conservative colleague had become “very confused because her husband has Alzheimer’s [disease]” did not breach Havering Council’s code of conduct, a standards panel found.

Cllr Georgina Galpin was told she was confused about the selecion processCllr Georgina Galpin was told she was confused about the selecion process

Instead, the comment, made to the Recorder last February by Tory councillor Damian White about Cllr Georgina Galpin, whose husband suffers from the brain disease, amounted to freedom of speech under the Human Rights Act, according to the council’s deputy monitoring officer Stephen Doye.

Cllr White’s words came on the back of the decision made in January last year by the Romford Conservative Association (RCA), of which Cllr White is deputy chairman, to replace Cllr Galpin as a candidate in the Hylands ward in this month’s borough elections.

But Cllr Galpin, who has stood in Hylands for more than a decade, claimed she was only made aware of the decision in a small announcement entitled “So long, farewell!” as part of RCA leaflets distributed throughout Hornchurch.

When contacted by the Recorder at the time, Cllr White said Cllr Galpin didn’t understand that plans made for her to run in a different ward prevented her from standing in Hylands.

He said: “She has become very confused because her husband has Alzheimer’s.”

The comment sparked complaints from four people to the council, including by Cllr Galpin and by Residents’ Association member Cllr Barbara Matthews.

They claimed that Cllr White’s statement caused offence because it: amounted to “disability discrimination”; “questions Cllr Galpin’s mental state”; was “highly offensive to everyone caring for someone suffering from this condition”; “crossed the line in decency”; “suggests that Cllr Galpin has somehow ‘caught’ her husband’s dementia”; and “bullies and belittles Cllr Galpin”.

But the standards sub-committee, which heard evidence in March, disagreed.

Instead, the members backed Mr Doye’s findings that Cllr White had not been acting in his capacity as a councillor when talking to the Recorder, so did not break the council’s code of conduct, and that even if he had been, the comment was “not unlawful” and was his freedom of expression.

Mr Doye said: “I think it is also noteworthy that Cllr White cannot see that there is anything offensive in the statement.”

Cllr White did not want to comment on the report.

Read more:

Hornchurch councillor Georgina Galpin hits out at ‘Alzheimer’s’ comment by deputy Tory chairman

Deputy leader slams Romford Tory for turning up to full council two hours late

Havering councillor Damian White claims his election was valid amid investigation

Havering Council hearings panel finds Cllr Damian White has not breached members’ code of conduct

Latest News Stories

Yesterday, 12:00
Natalie's son Oliver was diagnosed with severe Plagiocephaly and Brachycephaly (known as flat head syndrome) - this is distortion of the skull with causes his head to be an irregular shape.  The condition can be rectified with a custom made helmet which would re-correct the problem but the NHS does not fund this treatment  Natalie Allen with Oliver age six months.

A mum-of-one is “disgusted” that treatment for her son’s condition is not funded by the NHS as it is deemed as a “cosmetic” process.

Yesterday, 09:00
Langtons House, now Havering Registry Office in Billet Lane

When a housewife agreed to look into the family history of an old friend she had no idea she would uncover a lost story of wealth and power that transcended continents and had its foundation in Havering.

Saturday, January 31, 2015
Donna Marie Foster with her dog JJ. She is holding a charity event for her 50th birthday to raise money for charity

A woman who has had two near-death experiences is now living life to the full and holding a massive fundraiser to celebrate her 50th birthday.

Saturday, January 31, 2015
Janine Webber speaking at the Holocaust Memorial Day reception at Romford and District Synagogue

Janine Webber grew up in the Polish city of Lwow, surrounded by her loving mother, father and brother.

But her life was ripped apart by the horrors unleashed by the Nazis and at a time when she should have been enjoying the frivolity of childhood, she was all but alone.

Most read news

WW100

Click on the banner above for full coverage of the centenary commemorations of the outbreak of the First World War.

News from your area

Digital Edition

Image
Read the Romford Recorder e-edition today E-edition
Family Notices 24
Our trusted business finder

People thought the Deputy Prime Minister was pretty funny actually.

Brothers: The David Haines Story, will be broadcast on BBC Radio Scotland at 10.30am on Sunday.

Over £30,000 has been raised in a couple of days for a mugging victim, despite the goal only being set at £500.