“Dysfunctional” and “vexatious” behaviour causing low staff morale in Brentwood Council, says damning report

13:57 20 February 2014

Leader of Brentwood Council Cllr Louise McKinlay

Leader of Brentwood Council Cllr Louise McKinlay


The behaviour of Brentwood councillors has been blasted as “dysfunctional” and “vexatious” in a damning review.

The key damning remarks

These are some of the damning remarks taken from the peer review of Brentwood Borough Council:

n The current practice of constantly responding to frivolous and vexatious requests for information is draining capacity from the organisation

n The pace of much needed progress has been slowed and disrupted by the dysfunctional behaviour and impact of members and there is a requirement for the management team to take more decisive action to rectify matters

n Many staff we met don’t feel valued and morale is low... Staff cannot be expected to continue to work in such an environment

n The new constitution is being repeatedly used by opposition members to seek to interrupt the working of the council

n [Councillors and officers] need to understand and acknowledge what they expect from one another including defining what constitutes acceptable and unacceptable behaviour.

Morale is so low that employees say they can’t continue to work in the environment that councillors are creating, the report claims.

The review was published by the Local Government Association on Wednesday.

It did, however, suggest that some improvements had been made since the previous review in 2011.

The report says: “There remains a distrust between officers and certain members who need to understand the damage they are doing to staff.

“Many staff we met don’t feel valued and their morale is low.

One member of staff said they feel like “just a number on a payslip rather than a person”.

It predominantly blames opposition members for the friction with officers and suggests there is a “requirement for the management team to make more decisive action”.

Conservative council leader Cllr Louise McKinlay said the report had been “fair and balanced” and they would work hard to heed its advice.

She said: “It’s very clear that this lies with the opposition. They have a relenting approach to the officers, bombarding them with demands and requests.”

Lib Dem leader of the opposition, Barry Aspinell, said it was the ruling party which needed to shoulder responsbility.

“I think it’s embarrassing for the council leader,” he said. “Who wants to be associated with something like this?”

But he refutes that his group are to blame.

“I would come down hard on any member of my group who was treating an officer unfairly.”

The report also suggests that opposition members feel information is being denied to them so they must resort to Freedom of Information requests.

Labour group leader Mike Le-Surf said that they even struggled to learn the contents of the review.

He said: “Someone had to leak the document. It’s absolutely disgraceful.

“The Conservatives are running it like a leaky sieve; we might as well be as open as we say we are.”

Cllr McKinlay admitted “giving” the document to the press but denied it was a leak and that the opposition are given chances to meet with officers to discuss matters but “they don’t turn up”.


Latest Romford News Stories

Yesterday, 17:33
Residents from Orchard Village warn against plans for 750 homes in New Road, Rainham

People angered by a host of problems on their estate have staged a protest about the housing association as it presented new plans for 750 homes.

Yesterday, 12:54
Police were called after reports of an incident at the Thomson travel agency in Upminster this morning

Police are attending an incident at a travel agents with reports that the building has been cordoned off.

Yesterday, 10:00
Beaux Beatz members Jasmine Hood, Charlie Dillon, Charlee-Lou Borthwick, Tyresse Aaron Ryan and Macey Broom

Hoping to make the big time, young members of a pop group are showing they have the x factor by making it through to the live shows of a singing competition.

Yesterday, 07:00
Mother and daughter Sandra Goldsmith and Vikki Powell who are fundraising after both having being diagnosed with breat cancer

A mum had the devastating shock of being told she had breast cancer just a day before her daughter’s final day of treatment in her own battle with the disease.

Thu, 15:06
Canine partners, train dogs to help disabled people manage their day to day lives, take clothes out of washing machine, cards into/out ATMs etc.
The service is hoping to branch out into Havering but needs people to train the dogs.
Glynis Wotheboys, Andrew Skingley, and Emily Lawrence, with Garon the dog

A charity which hopes to attract dog lovers to train puppies to assist people with physical disabilities is holding an information day on Saturday.

Thu, 13:47
The girls on a saturday night out. Picture Mark Sepple.

Had enough of the Brexit debate, gorillas and 2016 in general?

Thu, 12:10
Rubbish left at Orchard Village, Rainham

Businesses have called for a cross-borough team to rid the area of illegal traveller encampments and tackle “criminally organised” fly-tipping.

Thu, 09:51
Ronan Moore, 2, and Riley Chambers-Cooke, 3, in the lift with Ian McCarthy, crew manager from Dagenham. Picture: Vickie Flores.

Families got the chance to take a closer look at the life of a firefighter as Romford fire station opened its doors as part of London Fire Brigade’s 150th anniversary celebrations.

Newsletter Sign Up

Most read news


Show Job Lists

News from your area


Click on the banner above for full coverage of the centenary commemorations of the outbreak of the First World War.


£3,000 goes a long way at Boots

Cosmetics, toiletries, vitamins and more. Boots is the number one choice when it comes to purchasing daily essentials.

Kit yourself out and go Apple mad!

If you’re obsessed with Apple or just love a good gadget, this is a prize that will blow you away! An incredible £3,333 to spend on Apple goodies! How would you like to be the proud new owner of the Apple Watch?

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Romford Recorder
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now