Plans to redevelop St George’s Hospital, Hornchurch, ‘abandoned in 2010 because of lack of GP support’

14:35 09 July 2013

St George

St George's Hospital (photo: Steve Poston)


Costly plans to build a polyclinic and GP surgery at St George’s Hospital three years ago stalled in part because GPs were unwilling to move onto the site, it has emerged.

In numbers

Total number of responses: 126

People who attended meetings and drop-ins: over 200

Formal responses from MPs: 0

Support for the CCG’s preferred option: 57 per cent (55 people)

Previously it had been thought the plans were put aside when the health trust that drew them up was absorbed into a larger cluster.

Dr Gurdev Saini, the GP leading the redevelopment of the site, also told the Recorder the people of Havering “overwhelmingly support” plans for a “centre of excellence for older people” on the site.

But throughout the three-month consultation period that ended in May, concerns were regularly raised before health chiefs that the buildings – which have been in public hands since the formation of the NHS – should be preserved rather than sold.

Collier Row GP Dr Saini said: “Everybody kept coming back to the remaining site and asking whether there were going to be houses built – and that’s not our responsibility.

The hospital has been shut to all patients since a Legionella outbreak last yearThe hospital has been shut to all patients since a Legionella outbreak last year

“I can’t tell property services what they should do, but we can say this is what people said, and see if they will consider that.”

When asked if alternatives could be found, such as leasing or renting the land to retain greater control, he said he doubted that would raise enough cash.

“But from the health side,” he added, “we are looking at building something that should give excellent care to all patients.”

Following the consultation, the Clinical Commissioning Group’s preferred plans will be adopted, with the addition of an education centre for clinicians, patients and voluntary sector groups.

GP Dr Saini speaking to the public at a drop-in consultation on the St George's Hospital plansGP Dr Saini speaking to the public at a drop-in consultation on the St George's Hospital plans

“We didn’t think about it but quite a lot of people suggested it,” added Dr Saini.

“They can have clinicians coming in and patients can meet together there like a support group.”

Another addition to the plans is an “urgent care” facility – a service to divert people with minor injuries away from A&E.

“We’re looking at care of the elderly and providing a one-stop clinic so people don’t have to go all over the place to have their care delivered,” Dr Saini added.

The health of St George's HospitalThe health of St George's Hospital

The plans are reliant on NHS Property Services finding a buyer for 90 per cent of the Suttons Lane site. The authority has yet to start looking.

“It was considered [in 2010] having a having a polyclinic but there wasn’t much interest from the GPs, so it was dropped because it wasn’t viable,” Dr Saini said.

“But now GPs have come forward to look at movement to that site.”

Among the issues for GPs was money that had already been spent improving existing surgeries.

Recorder FOIs revealed last year that the abandoned St George’s plans, which were never acted on, cost the taxpayer £100,000.

Related articles


Latest News Stories

Last night's full council meeting saw decisions being made on the release of £83million to build new affordable homes and the expansion of at least five primary schools

Councillors have agreed to release £83million to provide affordable housing in the borough, expand at least five primary schools to ease the shortage of school places and pledged to ensure more work opportunities for adults with autism in last night’s full council meeting.

Police were called at 12.58pm in the proximity of the Brewery shopping centre in Romford

Trains stopped going through Romford station after police reported a suspicious vehicle in proximity of The Brewery.

File photo dated 28/09/15 of Shadow Chancellor John McDonnell, who is warning the Government's failure to invest in Britain's infrastructure is putting the future prosperity of the country at risk.

Shadow chancellor John McDonnell MP is due to visit Havering on today to speak to young Labour members.

Robert Knowles serving food platters and salt beef sandwiches at the TapRoom micropub in Upminster, which opened on Saturday

The borough’s first micropub finally opened on Saturday and welcomed its first customers with locally sourced pork pies, cheese platters and real ale.

Yesterday, 14:12
Chancellor George Osborne outlined the government's spending plans in his Autumn Statement and Spending Review (Pic: PA/Yui Mok)

The Chancellor of the Exchequer George Osborne has announced his budget proposal for the next five years – here are the main things to know.

Yesterday, 11:56
Picture: Google maps

A man has been arrested os suspicion of stabbing a 16-year-old boy near Havering College.

Yesterday, 11:23
The London Fire Brigade has put forward proposals to axe 13 fire engines - including one from Stratford - to save £11million

‘All the conversation now is about social media, removing something as important as this is a false economy’ say Tories

Most read news

News from your area


Click on the banner above for full coverage of the centenary commemorations of the outbreak of the First World War.


MAC Makeup

MAC are renowned for their flawless, fabulous make up that is used worldwide by the stars. You too can have the chance to have the perfect makeup to suit your needs with £1,000 to spend on all the glam goodies you like!


You are never far from an Argos, wherever in the country you may be. They are like a magical cavern where whatever you need they seem to have it out the back behind the counter. So why not put them to the test with this great MyOffers competition to win £1000 to spend in-store.

Digital Edition

Read the Romford Recorder e-edition today E-edition
Family Notices 24

Local business directory

Our trusted business finder