Hornchurch mother tells of daughter’s debilitating illness as Recorder investigates HPV vaccine
PUBLISHED: 07:00 18 September 2015
“My daughter’s life was destroyed because of what has happened – she has lost most of her childhood.”
These are the piercing words of Hornchurch mother Nicola Kelly, 41, as she describes the impact of a debilitating illness called PoTS on the life of her teenage daughter Erin.
Like millions of schoolgirls, Erin had the Human Papilloma Virus (HPV) vaccine to prevent cervical cancer when she was 12, her mother believing it was in her best interests.
The vaccine has been described as “probably the most important thing ever done” to protect women’s health and is predicated to prevent up to 400 deaths a year from cervical cancer.
But not long after the jab Erin became unwell, her heart racing and her energy sapped by crippling tiredness.
After years of ill health, she was finally told she had Postural Tachycardia Syndrome (PoTS), which causes abnormal increases in heart rate and, in its severest form, can leave sufferers bed-bound or in a wheelchair and severely disabled.
Other teenagers have reported becoming ill after having the vaccine and Erin’s mother is among a growing number who believe the health of their daughters has been harmed.
“The injection needs to be banned before it is given to any more girls,” she said.
Yet government health agencies insist it is safe and fear the clamour will affect the vaccine’s high uptake rate of 90 per cent and needlessly place the future health of young women at risk.
Prof Andrew Pollard, chairman of the government’s Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation (JCVI), said: “We have no evidence of a safety signal with the vaccine.
“But what we do have is very clear evidence that this year 900 women, who have not received the vaccine, will die of cervical cancer, and the vaccine has the potential to prevent such deaths in future generations.
“So the place of this vaccine in defending women’s health is probably the most important thing we have ever done.”
Figures from the government body that monitors vaccine safety, the Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency (MHRA), show 8,228 adverse drug reaction reports since the HPV jab was introduced, or one in 1,000 vaccinated girls. Seven relate to girls in Havering.
Of the total reports, 2,587 are classified as “serious” by the nurse or doctor logging it.
The MHRA admits the figures are high compared to other vaccination programmes, but says this is explained by the high number of doses given over the last eight years, the age of the girls who are old enough to voice concerns if they feel unwell, and the fact that the vaccine is given as two and previously three separate jabs.
A MHRA spokeswoman said: “The larger overall number of reports for the HPV vaccine compared to other vaccines gives no cause for concern.
“The overwhelming majority of these reports relate to known side effects that are usually mild, transient and common for most types of vaccine given to adolescents and adults.
“These figures cannot be used to compare the safety of different vaccines.”
In July the European Medicines Agency (EMA) launched a review to look at “rare reports” of PoTS and another condition called complex regional pain syndrome following the HPV vaccine after Denmark flagged up safety concerns.
Campaigners and doctors argue part of the problem is very little is known about the conditions.
PoTS expert and consultant cardiologist Dr Nicholas Gall sees about 20 girls a week with the illness and says there has been a “failure in medicine” to take symptoms in young women seriously with many simply referred to a psychiatrist.
Only a tiny handful of patients mention a link with the HPV vaccine but he believes it could be a trigger for PoTS in some very rare cases.
“I suspect if we understood the condition in any way we would say that in some people the HPV vaccine is the bit that sets it off,” said Dr Gall.
“But there isn’t really any data one way or the other and we should be doing more research.”
If you need support, or would like information about your case sent to the EMA, contact AHVID chair Freda Birrell by mid October on email@example.com or 07752 945 545. For more information on the HPV vaccine visit the NHS Choices website.