Havering councillors argue their rights in debate over Hare Lodge demolition appeal

PUBLISHED: 09:30 26 January 2018

Hare Lodge, Upper Brentwood Road, Gidea Park.

Hare Lodge, Upper Brentwood Road, Gidea Park.

Greg Campbell

A Havering Council debate about the demolition of a beloved period building saw councillors question how much information should be revealed to the public regarding planning inspector’s decisions.

The decade-long battle to keep Hare Lodge, in Upper Brentwood Road, Gidea Park, includes four appeals to the planning inspector, all of which have been denied.

Most of the councillors at the full council meeting on Wednesday, January 24, seemed to be in agreement about their dismay at the approved appeal to demolish Hare Lodge.

However, debate ensued about whether the executive members of the council were required to reveal the external legal expertise they had received, and on which the decision was based.

The Conservative group provided an amendment to the motion, explaining it was following specialist legal advice that a judicial review of the planning inspector’s decision was unlikely to be successful.

Cllr Damian White, cabinet member for housing, said: “I think it’s a shame. Hare Lodge is a wonderful building and it’s those special type of character places that we should preserve, but Havering is not an island.

“We are governed by rule of law which means that when the appeal was released by the planning inspector, they decided we must follow the rule.

However, some councillors felt it was still their right to know what advice been had provided.

Cllr Michael Deon Burton said: “I refuse to accept this announcement.

“I think it is a very slippery slope to keep members from viewing this information.

“I will fight tooth and nail for any member’s rights.”

Leader of the council, Cllr Roger Ramsey, closed the debate by emphasising his regret over the decision.

He said: “I fear that the Independent Residents Group are trying to adopt a very sad story for political advantage.

“If there is a justifiable case for a judicial review make no mistake we will take it, cost is not necessarily a factor.

“Case law is quite clear so if they want to pursue, he should try and get changing the law.”

At this point, the legal advisor who provided the expert opinion on whether to proceed with appealing the planning inspector’s decision joined the debate.

She said: “Members have access to information where they have a need to know it, and that is established by case law.”

The Conservative amendment was passed by councillors with a vote of 30 against 14, with eight people not voting.

Related articles

Latest Romford News Stories

9 minutes ago

Prof Ged Martin borrows from Shakespeare to celebrate a famous Havering factory

Wondering what the weather has in store for us this bank holiday weekend? Watch our three-minute Met Office video forecast.

The manoeuvrings at Havering Council on Wednesday evening underline why so many people feel that they can’t influence local politics.

Yesterday, 15:00

An illustrator has taken her first published book on a tour of primary schools to share her story about bullying and accepting cultural differences.

Yesterday, 12:45

As thousands of music lovers head to Upminster this bank holiday weekend for We Are FSTVL, here are some of the roads that may be closed during the festivities.

Yesterday, 12:37

Travellers hoping to use the District line this afternoon can expect minor delays on the Tube due to a signal failure.

Yesterday, 12:00

What’s happening in Havering this half-term?


The next step in renewable energy could be right beneath your feet as you walk through a Romford shopping centre.

There are many reasons people decide to join a gym. Some want to pack on muscle for strength, train for endurance, or lose weight. But did you know it also does wonders for your mental health? Two members at Romford’s Better Gym in the Market Place talk about their personal fitness journey and the importance of replacing bad habits with good ones.

Sean Watson, director at the family-run St Michaels Homes which runs Howard Lodge and Dudbrook Hall, answers the common questions people have about care homes.

Newsletter Sign Up

Romford Recorder twice-weekly newsletter
Sign up to receive our regular email newsletter

Most read news

Show Job Lists

News from your area


Having a brand new kitchen is something that lots of people want but can only dream of. Sadly keeping up to date and making our living spaces as nice as they can be is a costly and incredibly stressful business. Even a fresh coat of paint makes all the difference but isn’t easy or quick.

Who wouldn’t love the chance to go on a shopping spree. Imagine being able to walk into a shop and choose whatever your heart desires without having to worry about how much it costs.

Digital Edition


Enjoy the
Romford Recorder
e-edition today


Education and Training


Read the
Education and Training
e-edition today

Read Now