Mother: Why can’t my son go to school with eight cousins he lives with?

15:29 26 June 2014

Katie Garner with her son James and his cousins. James was refused a place in his nearest school even though all his cousins he lives with goes to the school.

Katie Garner with her son James and his cousins. James was refused a place in his nearest school even though all his cousins he lives with goes to the school.


A mother has attacked a decision that means her son will go to a different school to his eight cousins who live nearby.

Katie Garner with her son James.Katie Garner with her son James.

Katie Garner, 26, is due to give birth in September and said that if her three-year-old son does not go to Engaynes Primary School, Severn Drive, Upminster, she will be unable to take him to school.

She learnt this week that her appeal was turned down by Havering Council and her son, James Tibbs, will have to go to The James Oglethorpe Primary School, Ashvale Gardens, Upminster, which is farther away.

She lives with her son on the same plot of land at Laburnham Stables, Laburnham Gardens, as James’s eight cousins.

They are either going to or will be going to Engaynes Primary.

She said: “His cousins are more like brothers and sisters. He sees them every day.

“He’s going to feel left out being the only one not to go.

“By the time he goes I will be nearly giving birth.

“I have got other mums here who are able to take James to school for me when I am unable to. I won’t have any support – either I won’t be able to go to work or he won’t be able to go to school.”

A council spokesman said that her complaint was “carefully considered” but the appeal did not meet the criteria for an “unreasonable decision” so the originally school choice was upheld.

Miss Garner said: “I’m outraged by the appeals process. I don’t see the point in it. We are working parents and they are making it impossible for us to do what’s right.

“I don’t think it’s common sense at all.”

Read more:

A running joke? Hornchurch school places ‘temporary restrictions’ on break-time activities

Government approves new free school for Havering

Approval granted to expand three Havering schools

Latest News Stories

Yesterday, 18:43
The cast of Aladdin, which is running at the Queen's Theatre this festive period.  Pictures: Mark Sepple

It’s panto time again and this year, Hornchurch’s Queen’s Theatre is transporting audiences to the Far East for a tale of dashing heroes and dastardly villains.

Yesterday, 14:59
Lee Burkwood is the Green Party GLA candidate for Havering and Redbridge

The Green Party has chosen 25-year-old Lee Burkwood to fight for the Havering and Redbridge seat in May’s London Assembly election.

Yesterday, 10:48
The sorry state of Romford Market at 11.30am on Saturday November 14

Plans for a £2million project to revamp Romford Market have been called in by two opposition leaders.

Yesterday, 10:10
Wykeham Primary Schhol in Hornchurch. Pictures: Google Maps

Disgruntled residents have set up a petition for improved road safety to stop dangerous school-run drivers in their street.

Yesterday, 09:37
Darrell Page and Olivie Crowther are collecting chocolate boxes to donate to foodbanks before Christmas

A couple are collecting boxes of chocolate from all over Essex to donate to foodbanks across the borough for Christmas.

Yesterday, 08:28
Demolition work has started on the site of Romford's new leisure centre

Demolition work started at the site of Romford’s new leisure centre on Friday with building work is expected to start early in the new year.

Yesterday, 08:25
Junior doctors at a rally in central London last month

Junior doctors will not strike today after the British Medical Association (BMA) reached an agreement with the Government to resume negotiations.

Yesterday, 08:17
Emergency services were called to Upper Rainham Road at about 1am. Picture: Google Maps

A man is fighting for his life after a head on collision in the early hours of this morning that also left two others in hospital.

Most read news

News from your area


Click on the banner above for full coverage of the centenary commemorations of the outbreak of the First World War.


Win a beautiful monochrome tunic dress with Great British Life!

Great British Life is offering a beautiful monochrome silk tunic dress worth £179 to one lucky reader

Nike Trainers

Nike’s motto is ‘to bring inspiration and innovation to every athlete in the world.’ With this in mind it’s no surprise why Nike is the preferred training gear for most A-list athletes. Get an extra boost in your run or height in your jump with £500 to spend on Nike trainers.

Digital Edition

Read the Romford Recorder e-edition today E-edition
Family Notices 24

Local business directory

Our trusted business finder