Luke Harwood: Lead detective DCI John Sandlin says there was ‘no way’ murder could have been foreseen

16:26 18 April 2013


Luke's body was discovered near a stream running alongside Broadmead Fields, in Woodford Green


There was “no way at all” anyone could have foreseen how Luke Harwood’s story would end.

That’s the view of Det Chief Insp John Sandlin, the senior investigator in the murder case.

By his own admission, it was a hard one to work on – but the help of Luke’s family made it that bit easier.

“I’d like to thank the family for their support through an extremely difficult time,” he said.

“But every murder you deal with is difficult – and due to the seriousness and ferocity of Luke’s injuries, and the number of suspects, this was no exception.

“The attack on Luke Harwood was unbelievably violent. The injuries he suffered were horrific, his face was unrecognisable.”

Tuesday, May 29 was the first time DCI Sandlin knew anything about the horrific events that had happened on his patch the previous Sunday.

“I wasn’t on duty when Luke was found,” he remembered. “I came on the next day and was handed the investigation.

“I just sat there thinking: ‘Why was Luke killed and why was he dumped there?’”

But a year later, with the facts finally known, he doesn’t believe anything could have been done differently by the police or the council in the months leading up to Luke’s final days.

Havering Council had taken over the bungalow in March 2012, and Emma Hall and Tony O’Toole – James Danby’s friend – had moved in immediately.

“There was no way anyone could have foreseen what was going to happen that night,” said DCI Sandlin.

“A set of events that no one could have foreseen triggered what happened.

“No one could have known Luke’s accuser was going to be there and that Luke was going to move in.”

Tragically, the man who is said to have led the violence – Danby – shouldn’t even have been living in the house when Luke moved in.

“Danby wasn’t supposed to be there,” said DCI Sandlin. “But he was O’Toole’s friend and O’Toole was letting him stay in his room. The council wouldn’t even have known about it.

“Danby had a previous conviction for violence, and he’d been arrested for another matter weeks beforehand, but it had all been dealt with and he’d only spent a few hours in custody. There was no way anything could have been foreseen.”

He added: “The defendants acted in the belief that the victim had previously attacked one of their number. The woman involved was in no way to blame for the extreme and sustained attack that they then carried out and subsequently tried to cover up, and she could not have predicted what would happen.

“She has been crucial as a witness and I would like to commend her bravery in helping us achieve these convictions.”

Latest News Stories

Havering Town Hall.

Havering Council has approved releasing more than £83million to provide affordable housing in the borough.

Campaigners demonstrate in front of the Mecca Bingo hall in Hornchurch after Lidl submitted a planning application to demolish the Tower building

Campaigners battling to save the Mecca Bingo Hall building in Hornchurch are vowing to battle on and will appeal a decision not to list the building.

Borough commander Jason Gwillim told the Recorder it was

The Borough Commander and MPs have welcomed the Chancellor of the Exchequer George Osborne’s decision to scrap cuts to police forces.

Yesterday, 16:10
Recorder reporter Hayley Anderson with her national journalism award

Recorder reporter Hayley Anderson was highly commended in a national journalism awards evening in Birmingham last night.

Yesterday, 15:45
Time FM Steve Allen will host the chat with the Recorder's Chris Carter and Laura Burnip

A swan that got police in a flap, term-time holidays and Havering’s mirocpub were the topics covered on today’s Recorder paper review on Time 107.5FM.

Yesterday, 13:29
Ryan Machin and his mother Michelle Bennett at their home in Romford after Ryan took the last British Airways flight back from Sharm el-Sheikh to London

A 17-year-old who worked in a hotel in Sharm el-Sheikh was one of the last passengers to be repatriated to the UK and calls on people not to be afraid to return to the holiday resort.

Yesterday, 11:28
Two fire engines attended a house fire at an address in Park Lane, Hornchurch on Wednesday evening and a man was rushed to hopistal where he was treated for smoke inhalation

A man was rushed to hospital for smoke inhalation after firefighters were called at a flat in Hornchurch on Wednesday evening.

Yesterday, 10:57
Boys born in Cranham will live healthily for 17 years longer than those in Harold Hill

New statistics show the inequality in expectations for our children

Most read news

News from your area


Click on the banner above for full coverage of the centenary commemorations of the outbreak of the First World War.


MAC Makeup

MAC are renowned for their flawless, fabulous make up that is used worldwide by the stars. You too can have the chance to have the perfect makeup to suit your needs with £1,000 to spend on all the glam goodies you like!


You are never far from an Argos, wherever in the country you may be. They are like a magical cavern where whatever you need they seem to have it out the back behind the counter. So why not put them to the test with this great MyOffers competition to win £1000 to spend in-store.

Digital Edition

Read the Romford Recorder e-edition today E-edition
Family Notices 24

Local business directory

Our trusted business finder